Let’s start with a question:
[poll id=”2″]
I had an interesting conversation last with NQT Tim Handley about use of Interactive White Boards. He was planning a unit of work for himself and another teacher to follow and asked if it was normal for people to create matching IWB slides for every lesson as part of this process. Talking to other PGCE students and NQTs it seems that creating slides for every lesson is quite common practice.
This made me think about my use of IWB’s. During my PGCE I visited a school where they did just this; one person planned each topic and created IWB slides for all lessons which everyone else followed, almost like following a plan. At the time I thought this was great, as it got everyone creating good resources for the IWBs and using them, and I replicated this in my own practice. I remember boys in my first placement class used to love checking the number of slides I had prepared for their maths lessons, and came in very impressed one morning…
“Wow Mr Quinlan, 35 slides for one lesson!”
Fast forward to the end of my NQT year and now I hardly ever pre-prepare slides for my lessons, and there are several reasons why..
The first reason why my prolific production of slides wound down was time. It takes ages to prepare them and I simply didn’t have time as I took on a full timetable. However, as I took up my own classroom with no room for a carpet I also found there was lots of wasted time when I invited children to interact with the board. I was ending up with minutes per lesson wasted as children got out of seats, navigated around other chairs and tables to get to the board, then began interacting, then navigated their way back. Whilst this was happening 29 other children were basically waiting and wasting their time. 1 minute wasted in my classroom equates to 30 minutes of learning time wasted. Wasting lesson time is not an option.
I also started to ask myself who I was creating the slides for. As I found myself writing reminders on slides for activities I wanted the children to take part in, I realised that they were in many ways a crutch for me, an alternative to nipping over to my desk to check the plan for the lesson. “Put the structure of the lesson on the slides and I can still follow it if I panic”, I was thinking and this was something quite useful as I was starting to build up my teaching confidence. However, if the structure of a lesson is pre-defined by slides, it makes it much less likely that you will change the structure of the lesson to respond to the needs of the learners…
As I began to wind down with my slides deeper pedagogical questions as to their usefulness came to the forefront. Unless you are going down the road of the Lessig Method, more slides likely means more time with the teacher stood at the front talking and explaining them, and less time with the pupils actually doing anything. This is an appealing model of teaching in that you feel like you are imparting lots of information and you have the whole class focused on learning, but in their heads they could very well be focused on what they had for dinner last night. I really believe at Primary level the longer you stand at the front and talk the less real learning happens, so lots of slides is not conducive to a learner centered pedagogy.
I strongly believe that technology is used to its best to facilitate personalised, learner centered approaches where pupils are actively participating. Listening to me explaining slides is not active participation. Despite what IWB manufacturers claim, one child stood at the front interacting with the board, even with a few others helping them verbally, is not active participation for the majority of the class.
However, obviously there are some times for teacher led explanation, and so I still do use the IWB in these circumstances, but I still rarely prepare slides. The reason for this is that pupils learn a lot from modelling and ‘osmosis’, especially where ICT is involved. If I want to display some photos from flickr to facilitate discussion I could search for them at home, download them and put them onto IWB slides to load up again at school. To me this seems inefficient when I can just search flikr for them on the board. It is almost as quick as locating and loading the file, and I have also just modelled some good use of ICT to the whole class in the process (It is a good idea to check what results you will get for reasons of esafety).
Similarly if we are looking at a Maths problem, I could pre-prepare a great big scaffolded template on slides, or I could create it as we talk it through on the board. In the second example I have just modelled the structure for solving the problem to the whole class, as well as modelling some good use of ICT if I have used copy, paste or any other useful tricks to do it. Better still I could ask them to come up with the structure for the problem, but that’s a whole other hugely inspiring video…
As I wrote previously, a lot of teaching the age group I do is about the little things, and constantly modeling good use of ICT makes a big difference. Not using IWB slides is also much more sustainable in terms of my time, and encourages a pedagogical approach that makes much better use of the pupils’ learning time. That is why I largely don’t make IWB slides for my lessons. I wonder how many people do, and what their reasons for doing so are.

Leave a Reply